Guide
How to Spot a Fake Profile and Avoid Dating Scams
Eight warning signs, one quick check and where to report a scammer.
A fake profile usually has polished photos, a story that moves too fast, excuses for avoiding video and a request to leave the site or to send money. Ask for a short video call, run a reverse image search on the photos, never pay anyone and report anything suspicious.
Why this matters more than it used to
Scammers go where people are open to meeting strangers, and a dating site is exactly that. IC3, the FBI’s internet crime reporting centre, logged 23,159 complaints in its confidence fraud category in 2025 (cases where someone is tricked into trusting a stranger online), with more than 929 million US dollars reported lost. In the UK, Report Fraud said in May 2026 that frauds built on trust formed online, closely linked to social media and dating platforms, cost victims more than 102 million pounds in 2025, across 10,784 reports. Reports are the tip of it: in Canada, the Anti-Fraud Centre says only 5 to 10 per cent of frauds are reported.
Warning signs
Eight things that should make you pause
Photos that look too good
Professional shots, models and stock-photo poses. Real members have a few ordinary pictures that look like their life.
Fast declarations
Strong feelings or promises within days. Anyone sincere is happy to take it slowly.
No video call
The camera is always broken, or they are always travelling. Real people can manage five minutes.
Asks to leave the site
A move to a chat app within a few messages. The site flags this because it is where scams often start.
A crisis and a request
An emergency, a stranded flight, a sick relative, a stuck investment, always ending in a request for money or gift cards.
A story that does not add up
Details that change, a job that does not fit, or messages that read as copied.
Too perfect, too available
A profile that agrees with everything you say and always has time for you.
Pressure and secrecy
Urgency, threats to disappear, or a request to keep things from your friends and bank.
Check
A five-minute check before you share anything
Look for the verified badge
An ID or video check is a good sign, though not proof, so carry on with the other steps.
Run a reverse image search
Upload the main photo to a reverse image search such as Google Lens or TinEye. If it appears under another name, treat the profile as a likely fake.
Ask for a short video call
Suggest it early and casually. The person should match the photos and be happy to do it.
Check the story against itself
Ask about things they have already mentioned and see whether the answers stay the same.
Keep the chat on the site
Behaviour monitoring and moderation work there. Treat a push to move elsewhere as a red flag.
Common scams
Four scams to know by name
- Catfishing
- A fake identity built from someone else’s photos, used for attention or to set up a later request.
- The money story
- Weeks of friendly chat, then an emergency that needs cash, crypto or gift cards. It is the dating scam in its classic form.
- Sextortion
- Someone pushes you towards intimate pictures or a video, then threatens to share them unless you pay. The FBI received more than 75,000 sextortion submissions in 2025.
- Recovery scams
- After you lose money, a stranger offers to get it back for a fee. They are another scam, and Canada’s Anti-Fraud Centre lists them among its top-ten loss types for 2025.
If someone threatens to share your pictures, do not pay and do not reply. Block them, keep the messages and report it, and then use the take-down tools some services offer.
Report it
Where to report a dating scam
Report on the site first, using the report button on the profile. Then tell the fraud body for your country, even if you have lost nothing. Your report helps stop the next victim.
| Country | Report to |
|---|---|
| UK | Report Fraud (reportfraud.police.uk, 0300 123 2040), which replaced Action Fraud in December 2025. In Scotland, report to Police Scotland on 101 |
| USA | The Federal Trade Commission at reportfraud.ftc.gov, and the FBI’s IC3 at ic3.gov |
| Australia | Scamwatch at scamwatch.gov.au, run by the ACCC; IDCARE on 1800 595 160 (Monday to Friday, 7am to 7pm AEST) if your identity is at risk |
| Canada | The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre, online at reportcyberandfraud.canada.ca or by phone on 1-888-495-8501 (weekdays, 10am to 4.45pm Eastern time), and your local police |
If you have paid money, tell your bank straight away. The safety page lists the tools on the site, and the first-meet plan covers what to do before you meet in person.
Questions about fake profiles
How can I tell if a dating profile is fake?
Look for polished photos, a fast-moving story, excuses to avoid video and requests to leave the site or to send money. Run a reverse image search on the photos and ask for a short video call before you share anything.
What is catfishing?
Using a fake identity, often built from someone else’s photos, to form a connection online. Some catfish only want attention, while others go on to ask for money or intimate pictures.
What should I do if I have been scammed?
Stop contact, do not send more money and keep the messages. Tell your bank, report the profile on the site and report the scam to the fraud body for your country. Anyone who offers to recover your money for a fee is probably running a second scam.
Does SexyMatureLove check for fake profiles?
It screens images, videos and text on upload, monitors behaviour for suspicious patterns and warns you about requests to move to other apps. Members can verify themselves, and you can block and report from within the site. It cannot vouch for every stranger, so check each person yourself.